2020 – 6 nominations
2019 – 4 nominations
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play: Alicia Harabin, les Liaisons Dangereuses
2018 – 5 nominations
2017 – 11 nominations
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play: Adriana Spizuoco, Clybourne Park
2016 – 6 nominations
Outstanding Lighting Design for a Play: Elyse Halloran, In Love and Warcraft
2015 – 1 nomination
2014 – 5 nominations
2013 – 22 nominations
Outstanding Direction of a Play: Jessica Damrow Sherman, Hamlet
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play: Anthony Younes, Hamlet
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play: Mike Sundburg, The 39 Steps
2012 – 13 nominations
2011 – 5 nominations
2010 – 9 Nominations
Lifetime Achievement Award: Carole McGee, Past President
NJACT Nominating Committee Member of the Year: David Benson
Production of an Original Play: Words of Snap Crackle and uhm… Producer: Faith Dowgin – Directors: Ed Faver, John Dowgin, Mitch Ruff, Joe Porter, Cathy Zouves-Wrobel
2009
Outstanding Stage Managment: Tina Lee, Tales from The Porch
Outstanding Production of an Original Play: Circle Players, Producer, Pete Barry, John P. Dowgin, J. Michael Deangelis, Serena Hally, Catherine Zouves-Wrobel (Authors and Directors), Tales from The Porch
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play: Catherine Rowe, The Clean House
Outstanding Direction of a Play: Rob Pherson, The Clean House
Outstanding Production of a Play: Joyce Porter, Producer, Rob Pherson, Director, The Clean House
2008
Outstanding Costume Design: Jim Parks, King Lear
Outstanding Ensemble Actress in a Play: Robyn Mandalakis, Lost in Yonkers
Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play: Donne Petito, Playboy of the Western World
NJACT Nominating Committee Member of the Year: Carole McGee
Lifetime Achievement Award: Bernice Woldman
2007
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play: Ed Faver, The Drawer Boy
Outstanding Lighting Design for a Play: Joseph Porter, The Drawer Boy
Outstanding Properties: Jon Heron, The Drawer Boy
2005
Outstanding Direction of a Play: Jon Heron, The Laramie Project
Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play: Catherine Rowe, The Laramie Project
2004
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play: Darren Ross, The Cripple of Inishman
2003
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play: Joyce Porter, The Effects of Gamma Rays on Man in the Moon Marigolds
2002
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play: Carole McGee, After-Play
2001
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play: Terri Sturtevant, Marvin’s Room
Outstanding Direction of a Musical: John Mentor, Pippin
Outstanding Choreography: Macada McMullen Brandl, Pippin
2000
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play: Jeff Maschi, Bent
1999
Award for Outstanding Community Theater